Homepage  Homepage     Search on site  Search on site     To write the letter  To write the letter     Site map  Site map
Agro Perspectiva
We are on: 
   

Photoblog

 




Home > News > News

ADM, Cargill still pursue Syngenta over corn rejections

28.09.2017 15:00 "Agro Perspectiva" (Kyiv) Syngenta moved closer to putting a troubled biotech corn seed launch behind it with a US$1.5 billion settlement with farmers this week, but grain traders who filed two remaining lawsuits may be less ready to compromise, legal experts said.

The company was sued three years ago by the farmers and traders who said they suffered financial losses over its decision to commercialize a genetically modified (GMO) corn strain known as Agrisure Viptera before China approved it for import.

Its settlement this week with farmers cost it more than half its annual profits and came after it lost a case in Kansas and had to pay $217.7 million in damages to over 7,000 farmers (all figures US$).

Two lawsuits brought by U.S. grain traders Cargill and Archer Daniels Midland against the seed company, which is now owned by Chinese chemicals firm ChemChina, are still pending.

«The settlement could indicate a willingness on the part of Syngenta to make all of this go away. But the claims of the U.S. grain handlers are uniquely different than the farmers claims,» said Roger McEowen, an agricultural law professor at Washburn University School of Law in Kansas.

«Im not inclined to say that the willingness to settle on the farmer side of things means anything to the lawsuits that have been filed by the grain handlers,» McEowen added.

A study by the National Grain and Feed Association estimated losses for U.S. farmers and exporters at up to $2.9 billion due to market disruption after the seed launch.

More than one million tonnes of shipments of U.S. corn containing traces of Syngentas GMO variety corn were rejected by China before it finally approved the strain in December 2014.

Cargill and ADM, major exporters of corn to China, may have sensed Syngenta was not faring well at trial and decided they might be able to recover more if they continued litigating, Carl Tobias, a professor of law at the University of Richmond, said.

«The companies may have seen some kind of exposure and thought that they might do better if they keep some pressure on,» he said.

Syngenta said in a filing with the U. S. Securities and Exchange Commission in February that Cargill had claimed over $90 million in damages.

It did not detail why Cargill and ADM were not part of this weeks settlement. It is not unusual, though, for large companies, hoping for a bigger recovery, to pursue individual lawsuits after a class action settlement has been reached resolving claims by smaller plaintiffs.

Cargill confirmed its trial would begin in September 2018 but declined to comment further.

ADMs trial date is not yet scheduled, said spokesman Colin McBean. The company has «very substantial damages claims,» he said.

Syngenta did not immediately respond to further questions about its case.

Grainews

Agro Perspectiva

< Groisman on working trip to Kharkiv region All news for
28.09.2017
Swine fever outbreak recorded within Lviv region near border with Poland >

24.04.2018  
21:41 Ukrainian grains export exceeds 34 million tons
12:53 Poroshenko signed law authorizing local Councils to prohibit alcohol drinks sale at certain hours
10:14 Belarus has sown almost half sugar beets
09:17 Astarta sugar sales down 34%
08:02 Zubko to take part within international conference on Ukraine to achieve Paris Climatic Agreement goals
23.04.2018  
22:13 First-ever Ukrainian garlic processing plant to be launched
17:58 Sumy region agrarians started sugar beet sowing
11:05 Personnel changes at BASF
10:14 Ukrainian import substitution successful: Ukrspyrt launched a distillery standing idle over 3 years
09:17 Ovostar 2017 net profit up 2%
08:02 FAO: A bio-based, reuse economy can feed the world and save the planet
20.04.2018  
22:26 Sowing campaign 2018: Work goes on within all Ukrainian regions
17:31 Ukrainian sugar beet sowing within full swim
14:19 Groisman pledges to provide massive support to agricultural sector
09:53 Milk Producers Association suspects processors collusion
08:38 Ukrainian plums export significantly up
19.04.2018  
21:04 As of FY2018 Q3, Kernel faced 21.8% grains sale fall, 14% sunoil sale decline
18:51 Sowing campaign 2018: grains maize sowing started
18:02 Apr 21, spring national open-ended ecological event Plant a Peace Tree starts
17:13 IMF: global economic growth wont last forever
16:38 UN-sponsored group tightens controls over crop-attacking pests spread
17.04.2018  
19:36 Since early this MY, Ukraine exported 30.8 million tons grains
18:11 Sowing campaign 2018: early spring grains sown at over half total planned areas
17:02 Agrarian Ministry took part within forest planting
16.04.2018  
23:34 Azerbaijani Jan-Mar sugar export down almost twice
23:11 Ukrainian Apr 1 cattle number down 4.5%
22:36 Gnidavskiy Sugar Plant to produce organic fertilizer for soil liming
21:09 Trofimtseva: Ukrainian 2018 Jan-Feb agricultural products export almost US$3 milliard
20:03 Mukachevo local government, community achieved green projects successful implementation
14:15 Spring Field Works are in Full Swing at NIBULON
13.04.2018  
22:31 Groisman: Decentralization, agrarian support programs to improve Ukrainian rural areas situation
21:36 Openmind brings non-antibiotics chicken meat on Ukrainian market
20:48 Sowing campaign 2018: sunflower has been sown at about 90,000 ha
19:11 State Foods Safety Service, World Bank discuss agriculture support projects
18:52 IOM, partners reach over 140,000 people with cholera vaccination campaigns witin South Sudan
12.04.2018  
23:18 21 Ukrainian companies participated within FOODEX Japan 2018
21:34 Groisman: Ukraine/Lithuania 2017 trade turnover exceeds US$1 milliard
18:13 Nibulon widens cooperation with European bioethanol producers
17:52 Odesa Port-Side Plant resumed its second carbamide unit work
17:39 UN: Despite number decline, desperate migrants to Europe face greater perils
11.04.2018  
23:17 Ukrsadprom approved Government gardening support program
21:02 2018 sowing campaign: sugar beet sowing started
16:18 Made in Belarus expo opens in Kyiv
15:36 Ukraine, Turkey made progress within FTA agricultural goods talks
14:38 UN starts campaign to protect about a milliard people against yellow fever
14:25 USDA Revises Australia, Brazil Residuals, Reduces Global Stocks
13:35 Sub-Saharan Africa Drives Growth in Global Wheat Imports
10.04.2018  
23:11 474 investment projects are implemented within Ukrainian agro-industrial complex
22:43 Agroprodservice starts sugar beet sowing campaign
16:57 Artemsil Q1 2018 salt output 502,000 tons

Also available: 

Agrarian Week in digital



READ ON-LINE



NewsNews - News - News - News - News - News
BriefWeekly Reports - Free article
SubscriptionTariff - News&Reports
AdvertisingMagazine - Site
ConferencesForum AGRO-2013 - DAIRY WORLD-2008 - FERTILIZERS-2010
Exhibitions
For our clientsAgroNewsDaily - Ukrainian Grain&Oilseed Market - Fertilizers - Milk Monthly - Milk Weekly
About usAbout project - Contact
     Lenty.Ru   +
2002 -2018 © Agrarika, ltd.
tel.: +38 (044) 486-9171, 486-8119
fax: +38 (044) 486-8830, 494-4889
e-mail: info@agroperspectiva.com